HOUSTON: The 2008 recession and financial crisis slowed development of power plants to serve the $35 billion power market in Texas. Extreme weather in 2010 and 2011 strained supplies, forcing the Texas grid operator to warn that the power surplus was shrinking and that rolling blackouts could be more common in coming years.
State regulators have responded by raising the price cap for wholesale power in times of scarcity. But owners and developers of generators say wholesale prices remain too low to encourage investment in new plants.
But in 2009, power prices began to tumble as the nationwide recession took hold. The 2009 average wholesale price of power in North Texas slumped to $35 per megawatt-hour, down 43 per cent from 2008, according to Reuters data. Natural gas prices slid, pressured by booming domestic gas production.
US natural gas prices remain far below $6 per mmBTU, settling on Friday at $3.15 per mmBtu on the New York Mercantile Exchange. This has squeezed margins at Luminant’s coal plants.
The Texas power grid, already struggling to attract new generation to avoid rolling outages as demand grows, now may have to cope with a potential restructuring of the largest owner of power plants and transmission lines in the state.
State officials and groups pledge they will be vigilant to make sure generators and power lines keep humming during any restructuring of the debt owed by Dallas-based Energy Future Holdings, which was created in 2007 when a private equity group purchased TXU Corp. and renamed it.
The company, which relies largely on coal-fired power plants, has struggled as US natural gas prices have tanked, squeezing margins for generators fueled by coal.
This has made it harder for Energy Future Holdings to make payments on its more than $50 billion in debt, The company has retained advisers to help it with any potential restructuring, which could still be several months away.
“We now have to make sure the lights stay on in Texas,” said Texas state Sen. Troy Fraser, who opposed the 2007 leveraged buyout led by KKR & Co LP, also known as Kohlberg Kravis Roberts.
“We don’t have a voice in what happens in the debt restructuring, but we have a huge interest in making sure it is an orderly transaction,” he said.
“I want to make sure the generating plants continue to run, the power is sold to the retail company and that the wires company stays intact to deliver it,” Fraser said.
Unlike other areas of the country, Texas operates as a power “island” with limited ability to import power from adjacent states so continued operation of plants operated by Luminant, the EFH generating arm, is expected.
The Texas Public Utility Commission is studying a number of options, including modifying market rules of the “energy only” market” to expand programs that pay customers to curtail electric use when supplies are tight. Also under consideration is a more drastic plan to change the market’s design to a “capacity market” similar to those in other US regions, that pays generators to be available in future years whether they are called on or not.
Consumer Group Public Citizen has said additional revenue from a capacity market would not help the financial picture at EFH and would not lead to new investment in viable energy projects.
Fraser is optimistic that EFH units can keep power flowing to Texans without disruption through any debt restructuring.
But some are worried that whoever ends up with the company’s assets after a restructuring may have too much market power to raise electricity prices.
“We’d be interested in how it is going to be structured and who is going to end up owning the assets,” said Geoffrey Gay, an Austin attorney who represents a coalition of cities served by Oncor in North Texas. Gay’s clients have authorized him to intervene in any bankruptcy filing that may occur.
“The concern would be if any one company buys all those assets and thereby increases its overall market power in the state,” Gay said.
If another large generating company buys all the Luminant power plants, it would raise concern about the exercise of unfair market power, said Gay. “That would have consequences for prices.”
On the other hand, Gay said if the plants are sold to multiple owners, “it could ultimately wind up being good for the (Texas) market,” he said.
Gay said his clients want the bankruptcy court to honor the ring-fencing put into place at Oncor.
Natural gas is the dominant fuel for power generation in Texas, and sets the wholesale price of power. As the largest owner of coal-fired plants in the state, TXU’s profits were climbing in the mid-200s as its plants produced electricity at a lower cost than gas plants in the state but sold power at the higher price.
The investors behind the 2007 deal that created EFH assumed natural gas prices would remain above $6 per million British thermal units (mmBtu).