Classifieds | Archives | Jobs | About TGT | Contact | Subscribe
Last updated 6 hours, 33 minutes ago
Printer Friendly Version | TGT@Twitter | RSS Feed |
John Rentoul: Parliament will still have to choose if it takes control
January 12, 2019
 Print    Send to Friend

The prime minister has lost another vote in the House of Commons. For a long time after the election stripped her of a majority, she and her whips were able to avoid defeats, mainly by not taking part in votes that didn’t matter and by postponing votes that did.

Now she is running out of time and cannot put off the crucial votes on Brexit. So first she lost a vote on an amendment tabled by Yvette Cooper, Labour, designed to show parliament’s opposition to leaving the EU without an agreement. Then she lost a vote on an amendment tabled by Dominic Grieve, Conservative rebel, to set a new timetable for approving her Brexit deal.

This defeat sets the scene for the next one, when on Tuesday next week she is expected to lose the vote on the withdrawal agreement itself. The Grieve amendment requires her to table a new motion in the Commons setting out her plan within three working days of losing that vote.

This will accelerate matters compared with the previous timetable, which allowed her three weeks. But she has had long enough to think about how to respond when MPs refuse to approve her deal. Ministers say they are frustrated by her unwillingness to share with them her plan for what to do next. At cabinet yesterday she was said to be “tight-lipped” when pressed for a plan B.

But they have only themselves to blame. Every cabinet discussion is now leaked to journalists so quickly that ministers might as well meet in a TV studio. The slightest hint of the prime minister’s intentions would immediately become the top trending topic on Twitter.

We have to rely on informed guesswork, therefore, about what Theresa May will do when she loses Tuesday’s vote. But, first, will she postpone it again? That is quite possible. She might be so furious with John Bercow, the speaker, for letting Grieve table his amendment today, apparently in defiance of convention, that she would delay the vote again – to regain some of the time that has been lost by today’s new timetable.

On the other hand, she won’t want to run away again. I suspect her calculation is that losing the Brexit deal vote is a necessary stage towards finally winning it. What is more, it is possible that she won’t lose the vote as badly as is widely expected. Hilary Benn, the Labour chair of the Brexit select committee, still intends to table an amendment that refuses to approve her deal and also “rejects” leaving the EU without a deal. If that passes on Tuesday, it would be a defeat for the government, but by a much smaller margin than the 100 or 150 that has been bandied about, because it wouldn’t be supported by hard-Brexit Tories.

The House of Commons seems to have run out of patience with that approach, hence the attempt to speed up the timetable. But changing the timetable doesn’t change the choice. The fundamental trilemma has not changed: the UK can leave with the deal, or something very like it; it can leave without a deal; or it can postpone Brexit and hold a referendum.

If parliament is going to “take control” of Brexit, as the prime minister’s critics from both sides of the Commons claim, parliament will have to choose one of those three. How May responds to Tuesday’s impending defeat doesn’t really change that.

The Independent

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Post a comment
Related Stories
Tom Peck: Come what may
Never again let it be said that the House of Commons is out of touch with the British people. That it’s a cosseted elite. That it doesn’t know how the ordinary people fee..
Matthew Norman: May’s career is looking more like a tragicomedy
On the eve of Theresa May’s kamikaze vote comes a mind-blowing epiphany: for two years, most of us have turned for guidance to the wrong Jimmy Perry and David Croft sitco..
Joe Watts: UK has absolute right to stop Article 50 process
Giving the British public a Final Say on Brexit through a new referendum is the most popular path if Theresa May‘s deal is rejected by MPs, a new poll has revealed. An..
Nabila Ramdani: Will UK yellow vests go the gilets jaunes way?
The tools of radical political change are still dominated by French exports. Enlightenment philosophers from Descartes to Voltaire forged ideas that continue to drive the..
John Rentoul: May’s fatal mistake while selling her deal to MPs
Everyone has an opinion about where Theresa May went wrong in her Brexit policy. So here is mine. I think she went wrong when she secured the breakthrough on the backstop..
Advertise | Copyright