Classifieds | Archives | Jobs | About TGT | Contact | Subscribe
Last updated 3 hours, 56 minutes ago
Printer Friendly Version | TGT@Twitter | RSS Feed |
Raja Shehadeh: Israel land grab anti-democratic
February 16, 2017
 Print    Send to Friend

“If you do something for long enough, the world will accept it,” Daniel Reisner concluded in 2009, after a decade serving as head of the Israel Defense Force’s international law department. “An action that is forbidden today becomes permissible if executed by enough countries.”

As proof, Reiner cited the “targeted killings” Israel conducted continually until the practice was, in his words, “in the centre of the bounds of legitimacy.” The Israeli government’s latest attempt at legitimisation takes the form of a new law passed by Parliament. The bill retroactively legalises government expropriation of privately owned Palestinian land on which settlements or outposts were built “in good faith or at the state’s instruction.” In effect, it makes the illegal legal.

The bill offers compensation to the owners of expropriated land, but this is just a fig leaf to make the illegal practice sound fair. Israel is well aware that no Palestinian will accept compensation, which we consider a means of selling one’s country and forfeiting its future.

The ploy of declaring private Palestinian land as government property and acquiring it for settlement is not new. But the bill signals a further erosion of Israel’s willingness to respect the international consensus regarding the status of the West Bank as occupied territory, as confirmed in a United Nations Security Council resolution in December.

In 1979, I defended Francois Albina, a resident of Jerusalem whose privately owned land had been taken by the Israeli military and given to the Jewish Agency in order to build the settlement of Beit Horon. At the end of a long legal battle that lasted several years, the Israeli military court accepted the spurious claim that the transaction involving privately owned and registered Palestinian land was done in good faith and allowed it to stand.

Yet there is something new, and newly pernicious, about the latest bill. Declarations of private land owned by Palestinians as public property belonging to Israel used to be made by the military government. Now, the Israeli Parliament, the Knesset, is legislating for the West Bank as if it were formally annexed to Israel.

Two Israeli rights groups, Adalah and the Jerusalem Legal Aid and Human Rights Centre, have asked Israel’s Supreme Court to overturn the law, but the fact remains that the bill is part of a larger trend. In Israel, de-democratisation is proceeding at a frightening pace. Israel has quietly not been allowing citizens of the United States and other Western countries whom it suspects of being pro-Palestinian to enter the country, according to reports by Al Jazeera and the website Mondoweiss. More recently, it openly indicated that those who advocate the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement against Israel will not be allowed in. International law and such basic principles as the protection of private property and freedom of speech are being seriously eroded.

The Palestinians once pinned their hopes on the International Criminal Court in The Hague. But, despite evidence, the court never bothered to investigate allegations that Israeli officials and generals were violating international law. The Palestinian Authority is now reluctant to submit claims because the US has warned Palestinian leaders that suing Israel in international courts will lead to a severe response from the White House, including the closure of Palestine Liberation Organisation offices in the American capital and an end to economic aid to the Palestinian Authority.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will be travelling to the US to hold talks with President Trump. Netanyahu is likely to seek guarantees that Washington will issue no objection to the new law and do all it can to shield Israel from being sued in the International Criminal Court – a liability made greater by the bill. He may well be successful on both counts.

After all, Trump eerily echoes the Israeli government’s disdain of peaceful dissent when he says that Homeland Security will allow into the United States only “those who love us.”

Where, then, does hope rest? Only in an active and mobilised American public that is now beginning to stir and raise its voice, supported by institutions that are willing to speak out. At times like these, the public and the courts are the most effective guarantor of democracy.

In Israel, de-democratisation has been underway for a long time now – the half-century that the government has spent occupying Palestinian lands.

Under President Trump’s leadership, the US seems to be learning fast from Israel’s right wing. For democracy to survive around the world, and especially in the Middle East, it is more important than ever for the American public and its institutions to be heard, loud and clear, before the world begins to accept the unacceptable.

Tribune News Service

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Post a comment
Related Stories
Michael Jansen: Adding to Palestinian woes
The Trump administration’s regional policy is based on business-style deal-making that could undermine the stability of this region... The first involves cultivating and ..
Michael Jansen: Leslie Cockburn’s brave crusade
Democratic party candidate for a Virginia Congressional seat Leslie Cockburn is being branded as an anti-Semite by the Republican incumbent who has resigned his post beca..
Tracy Wilkinson: Trump support for Israel eroding US standing
The Trump administration has gone further than any previous US government in expressing full-throated support for Israel in the recent clashes that left dozens of Palesti..
Alexandra Zavis: Innocence martyred
A skinny boy named Ammar, who is 12 but looks much younger, spent Monday playing with his sister’s blue-eyed, 10-month-old daughter, Leila, at the cramped apartment where..
Israel spills innocent blood in capital fury
The United States has opened its embassy in Jerusalem, a move that has delighted Israel and infuriated Palestinians. The opening ceremony is at a US consular building ..
Advertise | Copyright