In also-ran debate, Nikki Haley comes out on top

Nolan Finley, Tribune News Service

For a couple of hours on Wednesday night, it was nice to pretend the Republican Party is ready to engage in a competitive primary season that step-by-step winnows a reasonably impressive field of candidates to a single standard-bearer who can put an end to the Joe Biden presidency. The first Republican debate was a good show, energetic, passionate and a true brawl over the issues that will motivate voters to the polls in 2024. For nearly an hour, Donald Trump’s name was barely mentioned. It was nearly possible to forget about the former president and indulge the fantasy that one of these Republicans might emerge as the GOP nominee. However, a check of X, formerly known as Twitter, where a recorded interview of Trump by podcaster Tucker Carlson, airing simultaneously with the debate on Carlson’s former Fox Network, burst the bubble. The Carlson-Trump sideshow was averaging 75 million impressions.

Nothing happened on the debate stage in Milwaukee to change the reality that the GOP race is still all about Trump. But since there was a debate, the temptation to treat it as if it mattered is irresistible. And who knows, there’s a possibility Republican voters will come to the realization that, as former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley said, “Trump is the most disliked politician in America. We can’t win a general election that way.”

Haley, Trump’s former UN ambassador, was the night’s clear winner. She was forceful, informed and in command. On the scale of presidential gravitas, Haley scored the highest among the eight debaters. At the bottom was young entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy, 38, who has been surging in the polls on the strength of vapid sound bites that touch on every conservative talking point. Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie nailed Ramaswamy, whose positions were as skinny as his suit, as the “ChatGPT candidate” — a perfect description. He was as annoying as a gnat, and thus the other candidates spent much of the night swatting at him. The attention didn’t help him. Ramaswamy delivered the most bizarre line of the night in calling Trump “the greatest president of the 21st Century.” If he feels that way, why is he running against him instead of working for his campaign? On Trump, the candidates were inexcusably timid, except for Christie and former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson, both of whom were unequivocal in calling out the former president’s moral and ethical shortcomings. (Trump, meanwhile, was on X saying of Jan. 6, “People in that crowd said it was the most beautiful day they experienced,” and lending credibility to the idea of a coming civil war.)

Democrats will assure abortion is the motivating issue in 2024, and again Haley came out on top on that issue, speaking to the constituency Republicans need to win back — women. She dvocated a compromise that would ban late term abortions but allow states to keep the procedure legal. Former Vice President Mike Pence pounced on that, declaring Republicans must put principle on abortion ahead of winning elections. Pence tried to speak to those Republicans who keep saying they like Trump’s policies, but not his behavior, touting the Trump-Pence agenda. North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum, who signed a heartbeat bill into law, declared his state the most pro-life in the country. If his state had a few million more people, he might be a dark horse for vice president.

It was disappointing to watch South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott struggle to find a lane. He’s a bright guy, with an inspiring life story, but proved himself not ready for prime time. Now, the biggest loser. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis did nothing to reverse his slide. He’s got a great record in Florida, but he presented as shrill and perpetually angry. Again, this very likely is a moot exercise. I’d be shocked if today’s polls show Trump lost ground for not being in Milwaukee. But it was therapeutic to live briefly in a make-believe world in which the Republican Party had moved beyond Trump.