France’s pensions battle could ignite political crisis

Leigh Thomas, Reuters

President Emmanuel Macron braved strikes and street protests to force through a deeply unpopular reform in 2023 raising France’s retirement age by two years to 64, saying it was the only way to keep the generous but costly pension system afloat. Now an assessment this week by the country’s independent public audit office on the size of the pension deficit could rekindle debate about the divisive reform and plunge Macron’s fragile, debt-laden government back into crisis. Francois Bayrou, Macron’s latest prime minister, requested the audit office’s definitive judgement of the shortfall — estimates of which range from 6 billion to 45 billion euros after he offered to renegotiate the pensions overhaul in exchange for support from Socialist lawmakers. Unions and opposition parties from the left and far right want Macron’s signature reform scrapped. As part of his offer, Bayrou, a long-time debt hawk, asked employers and unions to form a “conclave” to design a more acceptable reform.

He also weighed in with his own view on the pension shortfall, estimated at 6 billion euros ($6.3 billion) by the independent pension advisory council. Bayrou said the actual gap between contributions from workers and employers and payouts was as much as 45 billion euros annually, disregarding taxpayer-funded subsidies that are used to narrow the deficit. If the public audit office concurs on Thursday with Bayrou’s estimate of a larger shortfall, it could undermine the left’s argument that France can afford to reverse the increase in retirement age and likely reassure investors fretting about the state of France’s rickety public finances.

Many economists consider raising the pension age an essential move to adapt the country’s public finances to a rapidly ageing population. However, if the auditor judges the shortfall to be in line with the advisory council’s estimates, it will likely embolden those pushing to lower the retirement age, bringing the pensions debate back to the forefront of French politics. Jean-Daniel Levy, from pollster Harris Interactive, said the pensions issue could plunge France back into chaos. France’s biggest union, the moderate CFDT, has already said it will abandon the talks if they’re based on the bigger shortfall. “We won’t be there if it’s a fake presentation of the pension system’s finances,” CFDT head Marylise Leon told France Info radio earlier this month.

Meanwhile, employers’ federations are cautious about any changes that would leave them paying more into the pension pot. The stakes are high for Bayrou, who has already survived five no-confidence motions. He had to make billions of euros in concessions to get the 2025 budget approved after failure to pass the legislation led to the ouster of his predecessor, Michel Barnier. Investors, ratings agencies and Paris’ European Union partners — wary after France’s budget deficit spiralled out of control in the last two years — are closely watching the talks for signs the pension system’s finances could come out weaker.

“It’s going to be an extremely complicated discussion given the constraints, socially, financially, and politically,” Moody’s senior credit officer Olivier Chemla told Reuters.

“Any change deteriorating or reducing fiscal sustainability would be credit negative,” he added. Bayrou has said that while all options were on the table for tweaking the 2023 reform, any amendments must not leave the pension system in worse financial shape.

Changes to the pension system are highly sensitive as many are deeply attached to the principle that payroll contributions from workers fund payouts to retirees. In reality, workers and employers’ payroll contributions only cover part of the pension payouts.